Moving from American Samoa to New Jersey: Residency, Taxes, and What to Prove

No. Guam, the USVI, and the CNMI use a 'mirror code' that applies the U.S. Internal Revenue Code word for word with the territory's name substituted in. American Samoa has its own separate and independent tax system: A.S.C.A. section 11.0403 incorporates much of the Internal Revenue Code by reference, so the law is modeled on federal law, but rates and specific rules are set independently by the American Samoa Government, not automatically updated when Congress changes the federal code.

Not in the sense most people mean. There is no separate New Jersey tax charged for the act of leaving. What exists is a withholding requirement, GIT/REP, collected at the closing table when a nonresident sells New Jersey real estate, equal to the greater of 2% of the sale price or the estimated gain at the top 10.75% rate. That withholding is credited against your actual New Jersey tax bill when you file, and if you still resided in New Jersey when the deed transferred, it does not apply at all.

Generally, no. Over 90% of American Samoa's land is communally owned by extended families under the matai (chief) system, and non-natives cannot acquire that land outright; transferring communal land to individual ownership requires Land Commission recommendation and Governor approval, or 30 years of adverse possession. Most non-native residents live under a long-term lease rather than owning a home, which changes what proof-of-residence documentation looks like compared to anywhere else in this guide.

Selling the home removes it as evidence, but it does not automatically end exposure. Samuelsson v. Director shows New Jersey courts presume domicile continues at its last established location until a taxpayer proves both intent to abandon it and establishment of a new one; in that case, never selling the New Jersey house was decisive against the taxpayers. Selling the house, not renewing New Jersey vehicle registration, and not returning quickly all matter more than any single document like a Florida driver's license.

If you're a bona fide American Samoa resident under the federal presence, tax home, and closer connection tests, your American Samoa-source income is generally exempt from U.S. federal tax. You do need to report worldwide income on your American Samoa return, and if you have non-American Samoa-source income above the filing threshold, you'll still need to file a U.S. return excluding the American Samoa income using Form 4563.

Not under New Jersey's own convenience of the employer rule, at least not for that reason. New Jersey's 2023 convenience rule only reaches nonresidents from states that impose their own convenience rule on New Jersey residents, currently Delaware, Nebraska, and New York. So a New York resident telecommuting for a New Jersey employer can actually be pulled the other direction, by New York's convenience rule, not New Jersey's, depending on which state's rule the facts trigger first.

No, and this is a common and costly misunderstanding. Publication 570 specifically requires that wages and cost-of-living allowances paid by the U.S. Government for services performed in American Samoa be included in gross income on both your U.S. and American Samoa income tax returns, regardless of whether you are a bona fide American Samoa resident. A foreign tax credit is available for the American Samoa tax paid on the same income to avoid double taxation, but the U.S. filing obligation itself does not go away.

It can. ANCHOR requires the property to be your principal residence as of the program's set date, so continuing to receive it on a New Jersey home while filing a nonresident return and claiming domicile elsewhere is a direct contradiction the Division of Taxation can cross-check. If you've genuinely moved, stopping ANCHOR enrollment on the New Jersey property is one of the administrative steps that supports your new residency claim.

People born in American Samoa are U.S. nationals, not automatically U.S. citizens, unless a parent was a U.S. citizen or they separately naturalize. This status allows a U.S. passport and mainland residency rights, but American Samoa residents, whether national or citizen, do not vote in U.S. presidential elections, and the territory's Congressional delegate is non-voting. Local territorial elections are separately administered by the American Samoa Election Office.

Occasional visits are lower risk than a pattern of extended stays, but the details matter more than the visit count alone. In Samuelsson, the taxpayers' return to New Jersey within about a year, combined with never selling the house, was enough for the Tax Court to find domicile had never been abandoned. A short visit to a sold or rented-out former home is far safer than repeated stays in a house you still own and could move back into at any time.

183 days in the tax year is the cleanest path under the federal presence test, but there are four alternatives, including 549 days across the current and two prior years with at least 60 days each year. Meeting a presence prong alone is not enough; you also need to pass the tax home test and the closer connection test, which for American Samoa often weighs matai title, extended-family (aiga) ties, and lease-based home arrangements rather than conventional homeownership.

Staying under 183 days protects you from the statutory residency test, but not necessarily from a domicile challenge if you never formally abandoned New Jersey as your true home, and it does nothing for New Jersey's separate inheritance tax exposure, which turns on domicile, not day counts. Many taxpayers assume the 183-day rule is the whole test; it is only one of two independent ways New Jersey can claim you as a resident.